Log In

Reset Password

Meet the 16 players who cracked the 2026 Butler County Football Preseason Sweet 16 Offense

The Butler Eagle Preseason Sweet 16 Football Offense includes three quarterbacks: from left, Butler's Nicco Baggetta, Karns City's Cole Johnston and Union/A-C Valley's Andrew Kifer. Butler Eagle photos

It’s easy to associate a quarterback with being a leader on the football field. They handle the ball on nearly every offensive play, and their performance, good or bad, has a profound effect on any game’s outcome.

The Butler County area has its share of quality quarterbacks, but leaders can emerge from every position on the gridiron.

Here’s a look at the top offensive players entering the 2026 season. It’s the Butler Eagle’s Preseason Sweet 16 Offense.

Related Article: PIAA high school football 2026: Butler County team previews, top players and fall sports breakdowns
Butler’s Nicco Baggetta hopes to build on a solid junior season as the team’s starting quarterback. Rob McGraw/Butler Eagle
Nicco Baggetta, sr., QB/LB, Butler

After passing for 1,375 yards and 12 TDs last year, Baggetta is battling for the starting QB spot in camp. His athleticism — he ran for 11 touchdowns and 470 yards on 115 carries — will be evident no matter where he plays.

Related Article: Here’s who made the cut for the 2026 Butler County Football Preseason Sweet 16 Defense
Union/A-C Valley’s Parker Bish, right, is a budding offensive star for the Falcon Knights. Matthew Brown/Butler Eagle
Parker Bish, jr., RB/S, Union/A-C Valley

He averaged 17.5 yards on 33 offensive touches as a sophomore and will now get more opportunities in the ground game.

Related Article: Meet the top 12 players to watch in Butler County during the 2026 PIAA boys soccer season
Moniteau quarterback Weston Cook, left, receives words of encouragement from head coach Clay Kohlmeyer prior to a game in 2025. Matthew Brown/Butler Eagle
Weston Cook, jr., QB/S, Moniteau

In his first year as a starter, Cook tossed for over 900 yards and 11 TDs. Look for better numbers in an offense that’s gone multiple to keep defenses guessing.

Mars' Smyth Dunaway looks to make the most of an expanded role in the team’s passing game this season. Ralph LoVuolo/Special to the Eagle
Smyth Dunaway, sr., WR/CB, Mars

He is Mars’ top returning receiver (19 catches for 239 yards) after standout Gabe Hein’s graduation and will see more passes coming his way from either Nate Walker or Colin Yurisinec, who are battling for the starting job.

Karns City's Shane Emrick (50) is now the Gremlins’ unquestioned leader on the offensive line. Holly Mead/Special to the Eagle
Shane Emrick, sr., OL/LB, Karns City

After playing guard last year, he will line up at tackle in 2026. All other starters on the Gremlins’ front will be new, and Emrick is the clear leader.

Moniteau's Bryan Hazlet is a returning starter on both sides of the ball for the Warriors. Rob McGraw/Butler Eagle
Bryan Hazlet, jr., OL/LB, Moniteau

He’s entering his third year of starting on Moniteau’s front. A guard, Hazlet is the heart of the Warriors’ line, maybe of the entire team.

Karns City quarterback Cole Johnston, middle, is seen here celebrating with teammates after a touchdown in a state playoff game against Farrell last season. Rob McGraw/Butler Eagle
Cole Johnston, sr., QB/S, Karns City

He’s closing in on 30 career starts at QB, and you won’t find another signal caller in Butler County with more experience. As a junior, he passed for 1,232 yards, rushed for 734 and accounted for 31 offensive TDs.

Freeport's Karter Kemp talks to Eagle sports reporter Brendan Howe during Butler Eagle Football Media Day on Aug. 6. Andrew Jackson/Butler Eagle
Karter Kemp, sr., OL/DL, Freeport

A rare four-year starter, Kemp, a guard, put on some weight (now 245 pounds) but still moves very well. His career has been marked by consistent improvement.

Union/A-C Valley quarterback Andrew Kifer turned in a very solid freshman season. Rob McGraw/Butler Eagle
Andrew Kifer, so., QB/DB, Union/A-C Valley

His 2025 campaign included 1,488 passing yards and 10 TDs while leading the Falcon Knights to the co-op’s best record ever ... and he was just a freshman.

Knoch's Makai Noah aims to block for a potent Knights offense this year. Jared Todhunter/Special to the Eagle
Makai Noah, sr., OL/DL, Knoch

Another standout guard in the county, Noah endured with his teammates last year’s 0-10 record. He’s ready to lead a line that will be blocking for skill players just waiting to break out.

Braydon Pomaybo, sr., RB/DB, Freeport

Freeport coach John Gaillot and several of his players compared Pomaybo’s ability to that of former Yellowjackets star Amos Glenn, who rushed for 2,362 yards and 33 TDs over the last two years. Look for Pomaybo to make the most of his one season as a starter.

Butler's Deacon Simko (21) celebrates his touchdown against Westinghouse last season with a teammate. Rob McGraw/Butler Eagle
Deacon Simko, sr., WR/CB, Butler

Whoever starts at QB for the Golden Tornado will benefit from Simko’s desire to improve on a junior season that yielded 32 catches, 457 yards and three TDs.

Karns City's Ronald Szczygiel will be one of KC’s top options in the running game. Matthew Brown/Butler Eagle
Ronald Szczygiel, sr., FB/LB, Karns City

He is a front-runner to spearhead a Gremlins’ ground attack dripping with tradition but has to replace plenty of yards that departed at graduation.

North Catholic's Will Waskiewicz (6) is Butler County’s most productive returning receiver. JJ LaBella/Special to the Eagle
Will Waskiewicz, sr., WR/CB, North Catholic

He led North in receptions last year with 53, good for 898 yards. Eleven of his 14 total TDs came through the air, and the Trojans are talking about finding more ways to get him the ball. He’s also a capable kick returner.

Union/A-C Valley's Noah Yori during Butler Eagle Football Media Day. Andrew Jackson/Butler Eagle
Noah Yori, jr., OL/DL, Union/A-C Valley

He was thrown into the fire as a freshman starter and has since rounded into a dependable member and leader of the front. He’s moving from center to tackle this season.

Mars' Colin Yurisinec played a major role in the Planets reaching the WPIAL playoffs in 2025. Andrew Jackson/Butler Eagle
Colin Yurisinec, jr., QB/LB, Mars

Another returning starter who is battling for his job in camp. With his stats from last year — 1,607 passing yards and 14 touchdown passes — he belongs on this list.

Related Article: How QB competition is setting tone for new-look Mars football team: ‘They’re yin and yang’

More in Sports

Sign up to Receive Daily News Updates

* indicates required
TODAY'S PHOTOS